Menu
Log in


Human Connections Matter - An open letter to the Thorns FO

07/24/2026 11:29 AM | Chris Spalding (Administrator)

The following is from the Rose City Riveters Steering Committee and is being emailed to the Thorns Front Office. 

To The Thorns Front Office and Ownership:

When the Thorns were purchased in 2024, the Riveters were looking forward to being able to start a new chapter for the club. We were able to meet with the new Thorns owners early, set up meetings with the new Front Office staff and started to build our relationship. We shared that we were cautiously optimistic about what we were hearing, and that we were excited to see the visions come to reality. We had optimism that this organization could help heal the damage that had been done to our community. Optimism that, even though there were a lot of people involved who didn’t fully understand the community that they had bought into, leadership understood that they were involved in something precious.

This year, our optimism has waned. We’re worried that  this club that we hold dear, that we loved long before you came to Portland, is headed in the wrong direction. 

At the start of the season, the Riveters Steering Committee wrote to the Front Office and articulated concerns around the front of kit sponsor, Ring. We spoke to you of our community, of the things we value, and how this felt unaligned with those values. In private and in public, we have urged you to reconsider. We have been ignored, our email went unanswered. Earlier this week, a new partnership with Treasure AI was announced, a business that is perhaps even more damaging to our community than Ring could be. The announcement of this partnership used images of the Rose City Riveters, our matchday passion for the Thorns, our excitement, and our joy. The marketing that linked our passion to AI has crossed a major boundary for us.

To conflate exploitive AI marketing tools with volunteer-driven community effort that exists despite the pressures of those very media practices is more than irresponsible. It is worse than a violation of our trust. It can be club killing. This approach risks alienating the supporters who stuck with this club in the worst of times, prioritizing fleeting trends over the community that built the Thorns' identity. It feels as though the legacy of overcoming the failures of the previous club leadership is now being undermined by a focus on corporate partnerships that do not reflect the values of our community.

Being featured in an ad that promotes the use of AI without our consent is a profound violation of our community. We have built our identity through genuine human connection, passion, and over 13 years of dedicated volunteer effort - things that an algorithm can never replicate or understand. By using our likeness to promote this partnership, our values have been disrespected and it has been shown that leadership fundamentally misunderstood what makes this club and community precious. 

Our stance is clear: we do not support AI. Beyond the immediate insult to our members, we recognize the wider, systemic harm AI inflicts on our world. From accelerating the climate crisis through resource-intensive infrastructure to undermining the integrity of human creativity and facilitating real-world harm, AI stands in direct opposition to the future we have been working to build. We refuse to be complicit in promoting a technology that threatens our planet, exploits vulnerable communities, and replaces human employment opportunities with imitations. This is not community building, this is a devaluation of the very people, human beings, who have sustained this club through thick and thin. 

At the start of the year, we said we would not be silent. We live our values.

We will continue to be in the North End every match, because the players are at the heart of what we do, and supporting them is vital. Our messaging will also reflect our values. AI has no place in our community, our city, or this club.

Featured but not considered,

Rose City Riveters Steering Committee

Comments

  • 07/24/2026 12:17 PM | Heather Busby
    Well said! Thank you!
    Link  •  Reply
  • 07/24/2026 12:17 PM | Janet Potter
    Thank you so much for standing tall and not giving in to the AI trend. The new owners need to understand our way of life and the love we have for our soccer community, as well as our town. I agree wholeheartedly with this message. As a 107st/Riveter, again, THANK YOU
    Link  •  Reply
  • 07/24/2026 12:48 PM | Misty White
    Beautifully phrased. I support this response and stand by the values outlined here!
    Link  •  Reply
  • 07/24/2026 1:05 PM | Dianne Brennan
    Well said!

    When I first saw the ad and the Riveters so prominently featured I had a sinking feeling the Steering Committee hadn’t been consulted. As a first year season ticket holder and 107st member I find some of their recent moves disconcerting.

    It created a cognitive dissonance, given The Riveters values and felt tone deaf to the larger Portland community, especially given the recent controversy regarding the funding for and use of AI in Portland Public Schools in these days of budget cuts to student facing staff.

    Thank you for taking a stand and writing this letter. I hope your/our voices are heard
    by the FO they take steps to mend the situation.
    Link  •  Reply
  • 07/24/2026 1:33 PM | Adam Toews
    Taking the "human" out of an inherently human experience is dangerous and short-sighted. You live in a city full of wildly talented creatives and marketing experts, and to pivot to exploitative AI is tragic.
    Link  •  Reply
  • 07/24/2026 1:55 PM | Chey Roberts Brown
    Thank you. As an Indigenous person,I believe the land and waters are my relatives. AI, data centers, capitalist extraction are all actively killing our relatives. All of us. We are from the earth and are the earth. This is unacceptable.
    Link  •  Reply
  • 07/24/2026 1:56 PM | Remy Hanson
    Feeling so disgusted and violated by this. We have given this FO so much benefit of the doubt, and repeatedly come to the table to discuss issues in a spirit of partnership to bring them up to speed. And yet they continue to make decisions that demonstrate they haven’t been listening at all, and in fact see us as a free resource to pluck from, knowing that our tireless efforts generate more interest in the club and contribute more to game day than pyrotechnics or sponsor gimmicks ever could.

    I’d be furious about this no matter who the partner was, but an AI company is almost comically horrible. I work in medical data and the amount of time I waste explaining to my coworkers why analysis they produced with AI tools is circular, misleading, or just demonstrably false is making me feel insane. And trying to reach customer service anywhere, for anything, anymore is hell. Anyone pushing for AI has zero respect for your intelligence. It was always a fraud, and those invested in it now just seek to minimize personal fallout. We can’t pay for their mistakes, and we DEFINITELY can’t allow our community and efforts to be exploited to that end.

    I love the Thorns so much, I’ve invited friends to the match tonight and I’ll be there, but I also think we have to consider what it might look like to withhold some of our contributions to match days until we see some pretty big changes. Our generous assumptions and good faith approach have not inspired them to correct course. It might be time to change tactics.
    Link  •  Reply
  • 07/24/2026 2:48 PM | Rick Rider
    While I have not seen the ad, I will be watching for it. I also agree with the concerns expressed and well stated, and will take each opportunity I can find to express my displeasure and disappointment to the Thorns management and their representatives.
    Thank you for the letter and for sharing our feelings in such a cogent manner.
    I am proud to be a 107ist and I will continue to support this organization as I am able.

    Rick Rider
    Link  •  Reply
  • 07/24/2026 4:59 PM | Erin Roden
    Hear hear!
    Link  •  Reply
  • 07/24/2026 6:29 PM | Nick Strecker
    So very well articulated and appreciated for expressing. I simply do not understand why the FO disregards the supporters perspective so regularly. It is what sets the Thorns apart from other clubs and yet they cannot build from that unique strength. Baffling…
    Link  •  Reply
  • 07/25/2026 5:17 PM | Scott A MacWilliams
    Hello,
    As a new Riveter this year, I'm proud to add my voice in dissent to this ludicrous new sponsorship. I believe AI is the absolute worst idea to consider for a team sponsorship. The scorched earth effects of it's cancerous spread is completely reprehensible. Personally I have seen our electric rates go up by 50% in the last 5 years, & more rates are being pushed now. Why in the f*#k would you want to support that??? That's not even adding the environmental costs that are not so easily tallied. Come on folks, you can do better!!! STAY AWAY FROM AI!!!
    Link  •  Reply
  • 07/28/2026 3:18 PM | Matthew Nye
    Happy to be the sole dissenting voice here and welcome the repercussions of it.

    This letter is not representative of everyone in the Riveters community.

    The tone betrays ignorance of what AI is and what it represents. It portrays a paranoia that was gleaned from sci-fi movies and social media influencers.

    The baseless claims of "evil AI" stems from not understanding how something bigger than you works and feeling powerless to gain that understanding or control it. That is something Im sympathetic to but not fear mongering and isolationism.

    I find it ironic that this letter was posted with no input from your members while simultaneously accusing the FO of ignoring you. This merely feels like the board deciding they dont like something and using the platform to amplify it.

    Your claims of this partnership insulting your members and causing harm to the environment are toothless in light of the fact that each and every one of us has been using what you term AI for years if not decades. From Bayesian and ML classifiers in email (AKA spam filters, folder rules, summary previews, ect), spell check/autocomplete or in-line translation, large-scale information retrieval systems (AKA search engines), every time you put an address in Google Maps/Apple Maps/Waze and just in general using any function on your smart phone.

    I have seen so much amazing art at the hands of people that understand what art is and how its created. That art isnt limited to the canvas, the medium or the process. And ranting about the evils without an in-depth discussion and framework is like the silent movie actors and actresses of the 1920s saying "talkies" were just a fad that was ruining cinema and the art form.

    Skynet isnt about to come online. We arent going to have to scorch the sky to kill off the robots and retreat underground to await the arrival of Neo. This is a soccer team that procured a decent sponsorship from a company that has been around for 15 years, specializing in helping marketing and sales teams be more efficient. AI is just a branding of everything we've been doing and everyones jumping on the vernacular bandwagon right now.

    But if youre looking for the combination of a more community supportive sponsor married with a soccer watching experience, might I suggest the Cherry Bombs, who are sponsored by Planned Parenthood. Im a season ticket holder and the inaugural season was a blast.
    Link  •  Reply


Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software