—by Chris Rifer
No, it wasn’t pretty. Yes, it is still preseason. But no, it wasn’t awful either.
The Portland Timbers played the San Jose Earthquakes to a draw on Monday night in front of some 16,000 supporters eager to catch the first glimpse of their team in 2012.
What they caught a glimpse of was something akin to their team, but ultimately fell short of the real deal.
The Timbers, missing somewhere between five and seven likely opening day starters, started the chances off early when Diego Chara burst through the Quakes defense into the box looking poised to tap the ball by keeper Jon Busch. At the last moment, however, San Jose defender Justin Morrow slid in from behind, whiffed on the ball, but took Diego to the ground. It was an obvious foul on a reckless tackle that ended a clear scoring opportunity. Penalty and straight red, right? Wrong. Play on.
From there the Quakes established several minutes of dominance in the Portland half, with the Timbers defense—starting a group that likely didn’t include a single regular starter—looking dodgy at the back. A few strong saves by early All-Star candidate Troy Perkins, however, bailed out the Timbers defense and kept San Jose off the board.
In the 15th minute the Timbers got one against the run of play in perhaps the unlikeliest fashion possible. After sending a short corner to Chara, Kalif Alhassan got the ball back five yards from the endline outside the box and curled it just inside the far corner. It was a brilliant effort from a guy who couldn’t get off the goose egg in 2011.
The rest of the first half turned into an up and down affair, with both sides playing some entertaining soccer, but neither side creating anything substantial in the way of chances. A header off a cross here, a scuffle between Jack Jewsbury and Steven Lenhart there, and the Timbers headed into intermission with a 1-0 lead.
The lead wouldn’t last long after halftime, however, as the 59th minute brought a needless Andrew Jean-Baptiste giveaway. After Tressor Moreno intercepted the rookie’s ill-advised pass, he sent it to Chris Wondolowski on the byline. Wondo sent the ball in front of goal, where Hanyer Mosquera took an unfortunate touch past Troy Perkins and in for an own goal.
The Timbers midfield, having fallen dormant through most of the second half, finally awoke in the final fifteen minutes. It was too little, too late to earn a winner, however, as the best Portland could do is create a series of half chances—the best of which was a Bright Dike header off an Alhassan cross that bounced torturously off the cross bar.
In the end the sides settled for a just split of the points. The Timbers advance to play Chivas USA on Thursday before a finale against AIK Sunday evening.
Match Notes
-
- The result and the effort were passable, all things considered. Sure, there were some things to gripe about. The midfield was nonexistent for substantial portions of the match and the defense had some forehead slapping moments. Considering the number of stand-ins, however, supporters shouldn’t come away from the match with too bitter a taste.
-
- I was a little bit surprised to not see more changes from John Spencer. Considering the number of key players missing, I thought Monday night was a prime opportunity to get guys like Sebastian Rincon, Brent Richards, Chris Taylor, and Charles Renken some run in a regular season-like atmosphere. Instead, Spenny opted for a regular season rotation.
-
- After watching the second half of the AIK-Chivas match, I’m convinced if the Timbers want to be competitive on Sunday they will have to have more experience in central defense. The dynamic way AIK move the ball around the final third requires a lot of discipline in the back line to handle the short, quick passes off of short, quick runs. Good thing both Brunner and Futty seem likely to be back in the lineup by then, because while AJB and Mosquera were impressively physical, they were by no means disciplined.
Timbers Grades
Troy Perkins, 7 Had the challenging task of managing a very green backline in front of him, and rose to the occasion. Was very strong during the early onslaught and can’t be faulted for the own goal. Overall a very promising start to the season for an in-form looking Perkins.
Mike Chabala, 5.5 Decent outing for Chewie in back. Didn’t make any great contribution to the attack, but gave a passable effort as the only MLS-experienced player on the backline.
Andrew Jean-Baptiste, 4.5 This is a tough grade, because AJB was solid for the vast majority of the outing. His mistakes, though, lead to the Quakes’ best chances. This was overall an encouraging performance for the youngster whose mistakes are correctable, and who showed substantial physical capabilities.
Hanyer Mosquera, 5 AJB bears the bulk of responsibility for the concession, but Mosquera’s touch probably should have been better. Still had a good, but not great performance in back. In my mind, it’s clear Futty will start the season as the Watson to Brunner’s Sherlock. That may change as Mosco gets more comfortable in the States and the MLS.
Ryan Kawulok, 5.5 Very promising effort from the unsigned right back. Something tells me that unsigned tag will be coming off shortly. Showed a pretty decent soccer IQ and very good physical tools. Has some touches he needs to refine to succeed at the MLS level, but given a couple years work he should be there. It is a little shocking, considering some of the garbage you see coming out of the second round of the SuperDraft at times, that a guy with the size and athleticism of Kawulok can slip into the Supplemental Draft.
Kalif Alhassan, 5.5 Had some absolutely brilliant moments, most notably the goal. That said, he showed that he is still the biggest head down dribbler on the team. Too many times Kalif was caught with the ball on his foot rather than finding the open runner. That, ultimately, is why he will likely lose his spot to Songo’o and Alexander. That goal was pretty sweet, though.
Jack Jewsbury, 6.5 From the beginning of the match to the end, Jack was the only guy in the midfield that didn’t disappear for stretches. Because of the 4-1-4-1 (to start at least), Jack was playing a little bit higher up than usual and was very effective in doing so. For a while I recognized as rational the questions about whether Jack is really the best option in the center of the midfield. I am off that bandwagon. He belongs. I also love his feistiness. Preseason be damned.
Diego Chara, 4 Had one of his toughest games as a Timber. It could be because he’s not completely in form yet. Yesterday, though, I think it was that he was playing out of position all day long. Even in the first half, when he was in a central role, he was playing way higher than he usually does. He was essentially in the withdrawn striker position many clamor to see Darlington Nagbe in. I think he was a little uncomfortable there. In the second half he got moved out to the left wing after Alexander was brought off for Nagbe. He was middle-school-dance-uncomfortable there.
Eric Alexander, 4.5 I like what he brings to the wings. I think he’ll end up there if, for no other reason, but because he seems very eager to get wide and send crosses in. That said, I just think he didn’t have a great day on Monday. By all accounts that sounds like an aberration from his previous form.
Jorge Perlaza, 6 There have been criticisms of Jorge’s first touch, and not for no reason. But mind you this: the Timbers offense works best when Jorge is making runs that bend defenses out of shape. Throughout the first half Perlaza made runs that attracted attention from the San Jose backline and created space for himself and others. This is the argument for Perlaza accompanying Boyd in the strikeforce. That space that Jorge creates with his pace and fantastic movement is exactly the kind of space a poacher like Boyd feeds on.
Bright Dike, 5 Actually did pretty well to get a head to Kalif’s cross, which was a bit high. Still, his hold up play needs to improve if he wants to make a serious bid to start at this level.
Darlington Nagbe, 4.5 Never really got involved. To be honest, looked like he was going half speed out there. Because he has missed so much time the last few weeks, I imagine that will be the case until the start of the regular season.
Lovel Palmer, 3.5 If Nagbe was going half speed, Palmer was going quarter speed. He looked far from healthy. If he was as healthy as he was saying beforehand, right back is Steve Purdy’s spot to lose.
Onward, Rose City!