—by Chris Rifer
The Portland Timbers logged perhaps their biggest win as an MLS club on Thursday night, knocking off Chivas USA 1-0 in a match rife with playoff implications. Before the match, many had professed it to be make or break, but for one reason or another it didn’t have the feel of a big game. There were no bright lights. There was only slightly above average giddiness in the Timbers Army. There was almost no national pregame hype. And yet, when you looked at the table, the importance was obvious. A win and the Timbers were right in the thick of the playoff race. A loss, and Portland was probably cooked.
Luckily for the Rose City faithful, the Timbers had a complete grasp on the importance of the moment. From the first whistle, Portland showed tremendous impetus going forward. Portland shelled Chivas early, culminating in a Kalif Alhassan 5th minute cross that Goats keeper Dan Kennedy snagged just before it fell to the head of a waiting Sal Zizzo planted at the far post.
For the entirety of the first half Portland would keep applying the pressure. The Timbers moved the ball effectively down the left side, leading to countless crosses into the box from both Mike Chabala and Kalif Alhassan. Chivas created the occasional chance—namely a Laurent Courtois strike from distance that Troy Perkins just tapped over the bar—but was held on its heels through the entirety of the first stanza.
For just a brief second in the 32nd minute it appeared as though Portland was destined to pull ahead. Jack Jewsbury sent a ball from the right wing into the box, where David Horst had muscled his way on the ball. Horst’s header appeared fated for the net, but at the last moment Kennedy switched directions, dove, and tapped the ball just wide.
In the 44th minute, the Timbers would stop teasing. Chabala, taking over the duties on corner kicks from the right side, sent an in-swinger to the near post, where Eric Brunner got just enough of a head on the ball to redirect it across the goal, past a helpless Kennedy, and into the side netting.
In the second half Portland would trade dominance for defense. Down a goal, Chivas began to show much more intent in coming forward, but the Timbers defense was more than up to the task. Led by some brilliant play from their center backs, prominently including the extra-human performance of David Horst, for the first part of the half the Timbers limited the Goats to efforts from distance that were easily mopped up by Troy Perkins.
The Timbers, meanwhile, showed that they could create some chances on the counter. A Kenny Cooper crack from distance was parried away by Kennedy. Kalif Alhassan’s chip from 30 yards forced Kennedy into action again. Finally, a last-ditch tackle forced Diego Chara to send an effort just wide of Kennedy’s post.
Chivas wasn’t done yet, however. In the 73rd minute, Marcos Mondaini sent a volley off of a long ball just wide of the far post. In the late stages, the Goats continued to pin down the Portland defense, as the once stalwart legs looked to get a bit heavier. Finally, two minutes into stoppage time, a headed cross fell to an unmarked Courtois in the box. This was the moment— the Rod Wallace handball moment, the Drew Moor moment—that had haunted the Timbers all season. This time, though, Courtois had his steps mixed up. Instead of a clinical finish with the right, he was forced into an awkward stab with his left. His effort sailed wide, and Portland pocketed three hard fought points.
The match more than met the moment. This was a big game complete with inspired play by the boys in green, thwarted opportunities, a brilliant goal, and gritty defense to hang on through the drama to the finish. The ramifications are complex, but can be summed up quite simply: The Timbers are still in contention.
Match Observations
- It’s too bad that match was buried in a midweek showdown on regional TV. That is exactly the kind of match that MLS needs to get out to households across the country to show that this league can be top notch without involving gimmicks like David Beckham. Make no mistake, on Wednesday night there were two teams out there desperate to win. There was fantastic drama. There was physical play. There was everything a sports fan could ask for in a soccer match. Except there weren’t that many viewers.
- I thought John Spencer was a little bit slow with his substitutions. By the 65th or 70th minute it was clear that some legs were starting to get a bit heavy. Specifically, Sal Zizzo and Mike Chabala looked completely cooked. With Chivas having to burn two substitutions early in the match, the Timbers would have done well to bring on some fresh legs, control possession, and make Chivas chase the match a little bit more. Instead, Portland seemed spent and had to retreat into a shell a little bit. With the exception of a couple nervous moments, it worked out well. But still, it created some pretty nervous moments.
- The last couple matches at home have been vintage Timbers.[1] Portland has gone back to the direct style that was successful for them early in the season. Portland has looked to play the ball up the wings a lot more and send balls into the box. The difference between this and that early-season tactic, to me at least, is the play of Diego Chara. Whereas in April and May the Timbers pretty much exclusively moved the ball up the wings, now Chara brings a different element. If given a little bit of space he brings the threat of being able to take the ball into the teeth of the defense. As has been thoroughly discussed on message boards around Soccer City, it is not necessarily the prettiest style of play, and it usually doesn’t show that well on the stat sheet (possession in the low 40s again), but it has produced results in the last two matches.
Timbers Grades
Troy Perkins, 6 Okay, not even the Perkins detractors could detract from this performance. Name one moment in the match where he did anything subpar. I dare you. That’s what I thought. He doesn’t get an amazing grade because he was very well protected through most of the night, but still, when called upon he was stellar.
Mike Chabala, 5 Chabala was fantastic in the first half. He was marauding. He was effective defensively. And he was Chewy on the Spot with his crosses and set pieces. As the second half wore on, though, he lost his legs and became a complete liability. Lots of his men—Justin Braun, most often—were left unmarked in the box. So, it all evens out to a 5.
David Horst, 8 In his poorer moments of the night, he was very good. In his best moments of the night he was superhuman. Most of the time he was somewhere around fantastic. There was one sequence in particular where he cleared three Chivas efforts in quick succession. I know Brunner scored, but Horst is my Man of the Match.
Eric Brunner, 7 I’m sorry pal. Any other night and you would probably be MotM. No, you didn’t do anything wrong in defense. You were really good there. And yes, you scored a really nice goal. I know, I know. I’m not undervaluing that. But seriously, did you see what Horst was doing all night? Don’t take it personally, Eric. David just logged the best defensive effort of the year by a Timber. And yes, I just spent most of Brunner’s grade space talking more about Horst.
Lovel Palmer, 5.5 Had a nice evening on the right side. He certainly doesn’t get forward as much as Chabala does, but I imagine Brunner and Horst secretly appreciate that. Still, he showed some signs of getting more comfortable in the green shirt on Wednesday.
Kalif Alhassan, 6 One of his better outings. Was great on the ball, and again was smart in mostly making the simple pass. Most exciting was that he put a couple on frame. A few more of those, Kalif, and you might just log yourself a goal. Baby steps, though, baby steps.
Diego Chara, 6 I love how active he is. He didn’t have his best night, and was somewhere short of ridiculously effective, but I would still say he was very effective.
Jack Jewsbury, 6 I noticed him more in defense than I usually do. Late in the second half he had one particularly nice sequence where he picked up a man in the box on the ball with his back to goal, shut him down, and made him play the ball out of the box. Just the kinds of things Jack can do that don’t always go noticed.
Sal Zizzo, 4.5 Wasn’t awful. Had a few nice crosses, and was maybe even a bit unlucky to have Kennedy pick off what would have been a tap-in goal. It looks to me like he’s still struggling through some tired legs. He’ll be as pleased as anybody to see the off week after D.C.
Kenny Cooper, 5.5 Did an awful lot of dirty work, and also had a couple nice sequences on the ball. I really like when he hits balls from distance. For having such great pace on the ball, he does a good job of keeping it down and on frame. When defenses are preoccupied by the quickness of Perlaza, that very well could end up being a nice way to tally a surprise goal.
Jorge Perlaza, 4.5 Struggled just a touch with his first touch. Even then, he came oh-so-close to notching a second straight assist to his countryman. I’ll also say this, Chivas was paying a lot of attention to him defensively. I better stop typing before I talk myself out of this grade.
Eric Alexander, 4.5 When he came on he looked understandably out of sorts. As the minutes wore on, though, he seemed to be finding himself a little bit. More importantly, when are we going to be able to find this guy some meaningful training time? Oh, right, next week. Don’t expect much from him until after that.
Darlington Nagbe, 5 Had a couple moments of nice possession, but was otherwise pretty quiet.
Rod Wallace, 5 Was the prudent move to make, but he didn’t provide much cover for the ailing Chabala. Can’t really blame Rod for anything, though.
Onward, Rose City!
[1] Okay, maybe not so much vintage as Timbers circa April and May.